Loading...
  • Self-managing landlords to face 17x increase in risk!

Self-managing landlords to face 17x increase in risk!

30 Sep 2025

This is an AI simulation showing the expected penalties faced by self-managing landlords before and after the Renters’ Rights Act. ChatGPT suggested a 17x increase in risk, whereas Gemini suggested an 18x increase. Below are the prompt and the output for both engines.

The Prompt

I want to make a comparative analysis of risk for landlords who manage their properties themselves before and after the Renters' Rights Act -RRA- comes into effect.

Using the Tort law formula of expected penalties (Fine x Probability), give me the expected fines today and once the RRA is implemented, considering the following: Fine takes into account licence penalties as disclosed in the press and on specialised sites like landlordzone, the NRLA, Kammadata.com and the likes, as well as civil penalties and Rent Repayment Orders -RROs- enforced today that you can find online; Probability considers the number of landlords in the market compared to the ones that are fined. Infer the increase in fines from sources like Kammadata and other online sources like councils, public records, and the press.

Once the RRA is implemented, use all the potential fines, penalties and RROs provided for in the RRA, considering that: council enforcement becomes mandatory, tenant enforcement is fuelled by the RRO enticement and publicity it will gather, and the expected reduction in the number of landlords given how many exit the market, which you can infer from online publications and articles.

Please provide me with the formulas and their corresponding content, including the sources for each input.

 

1. Answer from ChatGPT-5 with advanced reasoning (27/09/25)

Expected Penalty Risk for Self-Managing Landlords

Comparative Analysis: Pre-RRA vs Post-RRA

Methodology: Tort-Based Risk Formula

Expected Penalty (E) = Probability of Enforcement (P) × Magnitude of Penalty (M)

  • = Likelihood of enforcement (civil penalty or Rent Repayment Order).
  • M = Average size of penalty or repayment ordered.

Data and Estimates

Pre-RRA (Current Legal Framework)

  • Total PRS landlords: ~2.4 million (DLUHC / Explanatory Notes)
  • Enforcement activity(2022):
    1. ~6,540 fines across 50 councils = £327M (Kamma)
    2. Extrapolated UK-wide: ~0.27% enforcement rate (1 in 370 landlords)
  • Average fine (weighted):
    1. HMO offences: £10–30k
    2. Illegal eviction/deposit: £3–15k
    3. Estimated average: £9,000

Expected Penalty (E₁) = 0.0027 × £9,000 = £24.30/year

Post-RRA (After Renters’ Rights Act comes into force)

  • Enforcement becomes mandatory(Clause 97)
  • RRO max duration doubles: 1 year → 2 years’ rent
  • More offences eligible for RRO: misleading notices, PRS Database, etc.
  • Increased visibility via Ombudsman & PRS Database
  • RRO award automation for repeat offenders
  • Estimated enforcement volume:
    • 300 councils extrapolated = ~50,000 fines/RROs/year
  • Landlord base reduced by 10% (NRLA exit trend) → 2.16M
  • Revised enforcement rate = ~2.3%
  • New average penalty (RRO + civil): £18,000

Expected Penalty (E₂) = 0.023 × £18,000 = £414/year

Comparative Table

Stage

Avg. Penalty (M)

Enforcement Rate (P)

Expected Penalty (E)

Pre-RRA

£9,000

0.27%

£24.30/year

Post-RRA

£18,000

2.3%

£414/year

Risk increases ~17× under the RRA

Key Policy Drivers Behind the Increase

  • Mandatory enforcement duty on local authorities (Clause 97)
  • Expanded Rent Repayment Orders (RROs) for more offences (e.g. misleading notices, database violations)
  • RROs period doubled to 2 years
  • Repeat offenders subject to maximum RROs
  • Civil penalties: £7,000 (first) → £40,000 (repeat/multiple)
  • Public PRS Database enables tenant-led enforcement
  • Superior landlords and company officers now also liable for RROs

Sources

  • Kamma Data:
    £327M fines from 50 councils and 2022 record year for fines
  • Renters’ Rights Bill — final version
  • Explanatory Notes (EN_240008en.pdf) — 2025
  • Guide to the Renters’ Rights Bill – GOV.UK (May 2025)
  • NRLA, Inside Housing, tribunal decisions, FOI disclosures

2. Answer from Google Gemini 2.5 Flash (27/09/25)

Comparative Risk Analysis for Self-Managing Landlords: Before and After the Renters' Rights Act (RRA)

This analysis uses the Tort Law formula for Expected Penalties (E=Fine×Probability) to compare the financial risk for self-managing UK landlords today versus after the projected implementation of the Renters' Rights Act (RRA). The key driver of the increased risk is the RRA's shift from largely reactive enforcement to mandatory duty-driven enforcement, coupled with the doubling of Rent Repayment Order (RRO) maximums.

1. The Tort Law Formula and Inputs

Component

Before RRA (1)

After RRA (2) (Revised Projection)

Source / Derivation

Average Fine (F)

£15,000

£25,000

F1: Inference from current £30,000 max civil penalty. F2: Inference based on £40,000 max civil penalty and RROs doubled to 24 months' rent (Propertymark).

Total Landlords (L)

2,820,000

2,538,000

L1: UK estimate (Confused.com). L2 Assumes a 10% exit rate due to RRA pressure (LandlordZONE).

Annual Significant Fines (X)

1,000

10,000

X1: Estimate based on low visibility/reactive enforcement. X2: REVISED 10× increase projection due to mandatory council enforcement and doubled RRO tenant incentive.

2. Comparative Risk Calculation

Metric

Calculation

Before RRA (E1)

After RRA (E2)

Probability (P)

P=LX

P1 =2,820,0001,000

0.000355 (0.0355%)

P2 =2,538,00010,000≈0.00394 (0.394%)

Expected Penalty (E)

E=F×P

E1=£15,000×0.000355≈£5.33

E2=£25,000×0.00394≈£98.50

3. Risk Conclusion

The implementation of the Renters' Rights Act is projected to increase the financial risk for self-managing landlords by a factor of over 18 times.

Risk factor

Increase

Primary driver

Increase in Fine (F)

1.67×

Doubling of the maximum RRO period (12 to 24 months' rent).

Increase in Probability (P)

11.10×

Mandatory council enforcement duty and increased tenant incentive from doubled RRO payouts.

Total Expected Risk (E)

18.48×

The exponential increase in enforcement and likelihood of being caught.

 Boris Drappier

Contact me to discuss your needs




Other News
Quotation Mark Quotation Mark
  • Rent Happily has been managing our properties for seven years now. As a team they are fantastic, whether liaising with tenants, keeping up to date with any maintenance when needed, or making sure that we always comply with any new regulations. When we have tenant changeovers, they have been very quick to find new tenants so any void periods have been minimal. I thoroughly recommend their property management services.

    Caryl and Becky W. Happy Landlords
  • This is our first let with Rent Happily. We have used numerous letting agents in the past and we are amazed by how much better in every department this agency is. The level of organisation and efficiency is fantastic. They really know their stuff and are on top of all the legal, financial and practical details. Their systems work and they are responsive to concerns and queries. The tenant selection process is based on finding a good fit for the landlord, the tenant and the property. The commitment to treating both tenant and landlord fairly is something we far prefer given the lack of ethical standard commonly seen in this business. This approach really takes the stress out of letting out a property. These are qualities we did never expected to find in this business and so we feel very lucky to have found Rent Happily.

    Margot Y. Happy Landlord
  • I have happily rented properties with this company for over five years and have always been extremely happy with their professional work. They have always been there to help with any requirements. Great team to work with!

    Mark A. Happy Tenant
  • After nearly three happy years renting this house, I now have to leave. I'm so thankful for this time living at the house; absolutely everything has been positive about this experience. Thanks a lot for everything!

    Damaris M. Happy Tenant
  • I have let through Rent Happily for a few years now and can honestly say they are the best letting agency I've used. They are friendly, reasonable and incredibly helpful. I highly recommend them.

    Niamh W. Happy Tenant
  • Thanks for everything. You’re dealing with my application so efficiently and faster than anyone I've experienced before in this kind of situations.

    Matias J. Happy Tenant